What founders need to know about angel investing vs. venture capital

James McClure, a partner at Antler in Australia, compares angel investing and venture capital from his unique vantage point of being an active participant in both. Beyond obvious differences like the source of funds and cheque sizes, he outlines five lesser-known contrasts.


James McClure

James is a Partner at Antler Australia and co-leading the Australia operations. He is a seasoned C-level exec who brings over 15 years of tech operating experience across EMEA, APAC and the US.

Previously, he was the CCO for Adzuna, running its business across 16 global markets. Prior, he led the Enterprise business for SeatGeek and was GM for Airbnb UK and Northern Europe. James spent his initial tech career at Google in London, Sydney and Singapore; most notably launching local markets and YouTube across APAC.

Angel investing and early-stage VC investing have a rich history in the startup ecosystem, playing a crucial role in developing the biggest names in tech. I’ve been an active angel investor over the last decade, making over 50 investments in the UK, the US, and beyond. Now, I’m a partner at Antler, a global VC firm investing in early-stage businesses, and I've noticed some surprising differences in how I approach angel vs. VC investing.

There are the obvious differences, like angels invest their own money whilst VCs invest other people's money and cheque sizes are typically much smaller for angels, but here are my top five unexpected lessons and how founders raising money can benefit.

1) VCs raise money too

We all know VCs are investing other people’s money, but many forget that VCs also had to pitch for investment to get this money! Angels have amassed their capital through their hard work and efforts, but not directly raising it from others.

I’ve pitched Antler to angels, family offices, pension funds, wealth managers and more. As a result, I definitely have more empathy for founders pitching to me now as I’m living their experience too!

What this means for founders: Angels are typically empathetic towards the struggles of growing a business, but remember that VCs will have empathy for pitching and getting rejected - play into this psychology for your interactions with them.

Pro tip: This only applies to the partners / GPs, it won’t work with the more junior levels as they’re not actively involved in fundraising.

2) Importance of investment thesis and mandate

Nearly all VCs will have an investment thesis (what industries/markets/stages they will invest in) and a mandate (what valuations and cheque size they will invest in) published on their website.  Most angels won’t have any information about their investments at all, and only some will have detailed thesis and mandate.

Given their deal flow and networks, it’s likely angels will focus on specific areas - however, they do not have to justify to their investors when they depart from this. I’ve seen angels in a syndicate say things like “I don’t know the industry, but the quality of the founders and the Tier 1 VC investors mean I’m in”. By contrast, VCs have raised their fund based on a particular thesis, so to depart from that would raise questions. 

I’ve seen myself be much stricter with areas of interest and valuations as a VC than an angel.

What this means for founders: You need to understand the thesis and mandate of the VC very clearly, i.e. the industry, market, stage, valuation and cheque size. If you are outside of this, you will need to have very clear reasons why you are worthy of an exception given they’ll have to answer questions from their investors.

3) Opportunity cost of capital

This is a finance-y way of saying “what else you could spend your money on”. As an angel, I had a budget for angel investing, but that was a cap rather than a target. If I said “no” to an opportunity, then I could invest that money in stocks, bonds, funds, etc. I also paused investing for a period when buying a house as I needed liquidity.

As a VC, you can’t just say “Oh, I’ll stick this in an ETF” - and you’re much more closely evaluating each investment vs. other similar opportunities. I’ve said no to a VC investment I probably would have angel invested in because the valuation was 10x higher than our typical investment, meaning I needed to be 10x more convinced of success to deploy capital here.

What this means for founders: Ask if angels are actively investing and their current average cheque size upfront. For VCs, pay close attention to valuation and what else they’ve invested in to see what they will compare you against.

4) Follow-on investments

Following on means investing in an additional round of funding for a given company. Whether to follow on or not is a consistently raised topic amongst my angel networks, typically most angels don’t due to cash constraints, particularly at later stages. 

In contrast, most VCs will follow-on invest to varying degrees because (a) the power law of VC means that the lesser returns from a later stage are still well above the target fund return and (b) follow-on funding ability is a competitive advantage for VCs to get into competitive rounds.

An Angellist article explains the difference well; the median outcome is slightly higher if you never follow on but the mean outcome is higher if you follow on. Angels prefer a higher median, whereas VCs are pursuing outsized returns.

What this means for founders: Ask VCs what their follow-on strategy is and how much of their fund is allocated for follow-ons. It’s great to get that initial cheque, but you want investors who can continue contributing to your cap table. 

For example, at Antler Australia, we follow on in ~80% of the rounds and have 40% of our fund reserved for follow-ons. We also have a global fund which provides growth capital up to Series C. By contrast, assume angels only invest in this round unless you’re told otherwise.

5) What is a VC-backable business?

One of my most successful angel investments is a niche B2B media company. It’s growing, profitable and paying dividends but it can only grow so big because there’s a capped number of potential subscribers. I’m the only outside investor and it’s been otherwise bootstrapped.

A VC would not invest in this business because it has no chance of being a fund returner - the total addressable market is too small to do anything more than a 10x return. I’ve paid much more attention to market size (TAM, SAM, SOM) since becoming a VC to better understand the possibility of 100x returns.

What this means for founders: Think carefully about your genuine market size and growth potential - your business may not be clearly ‘VC-backable’, but that doesn’t mean there aren’t other routes to funding (angels, debt, etc.). If you are in an emerging vertical without clear TAM data, then paint as clear a picture as you can for potential investors on how there is 100x return potential for your business.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Get the latest news and views from Antler’s global community

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Must-read articles from Antler

Browse our collection of founder stories, industry insights and latest startup successes from Antler Australia

See articles
5 min read
Antler expands into Queensland, Australia

Antler is charting a new course for innovation by expanding our presence in Australia. We are launching in Queensland and partnering with the Queensland Investment Corporation (QIC).

Supported by the Queensland Government's Queensland Venture Capital Development Fund (QVCDF), the partnership is poised to transform the state's innovation sector. With a focus on bridging the early-stage funding gap, Antler and QIC are committed to attracting and nurturing the nation's top talent, driving forward Queensland's position on the global innovation stage.

5 min read
Bridging startups and industry leaders to drive purposeful innovation

As Jeff Bezos once said: “What’s dangerous is to not evolve.” While most business leaders understand that stagnation is fatal, for a host of reasons established companies often struggle to innovate—purposefully and powerfully.

Antler’s Business Development and Collaborations Group helps global corporates drive innovation excellence through high value-generating collaborations with Antler’s 1,000+ (and growing) global startup portfolio. In our collaboration with Investa, a leading Australian real estate investment manager and developer, we are connecting them to our global community of founders and the cutting-edge solutions they are building.

Read more about the powerful outcomes that happen when ambitious startups and industry leaders come together.

5 min read
The next wave of innovation: 27 industry trends set to define 2024

What will innovation look like as we move deeper into 2024? What are the biggest industry trends that will define the coming year?

We asked our global network of Antler Operators—founders, sector leaders, CxOs, and VPs from companies including Roblox, Airtable, Shopify, Spotify, Affirm, DoorDash, Uber, Hubspot, and more, who offer 1:1 advice to Antler portfolio companies, giving them extra firepower to help fast-track their growth.

5 min read
Antler leads $5.1M pre-seed funding for 37 startups across Southeast Asia

This marks the highest number of pre-seed deals completed in a single round in the region.

5 min read
Shaping sustainability in venture capital

Antler's third annual ESG and Impact Report discusses our commitment to sustainability as a strategic principle that's fundamental to the success of our firm, our portfolio companies, and broader society.

5 min read
What's in store for day zero building in 2024?

A brand new year, teeming with possibility. What can founders building from day zero expect in 2024? Antler partners share their on-the-ground expectations for the coming year, including sector trends, big shifts in VC, and the biggest headwinds and tailwinds affecting founders around the world.

5 min read
1,000+ investments from day zero

As 2023 draws to a close, we are proud to mark a special milestone: making our 1,000th investment in companies originating from Antler residencies around the world.

5 min read
The people who drive progress: Antler founders in 2023

Antler's global community grew larger, stronger, and more impactful this year, now including 8,000 founders, 800 advisors, and 249 Antler team members in 27 offices worldwide. Here's how we moved the world forward together in 2023.