What VCs should know about ESG and responsible investing, and how we do it at Antler

Due to the growing interest in responsible investment and therefore from VCs, the industry will need to become familiar with the concept of ESG. ESG stands for environmental, social, and governance which are a set of criteria used to measure an investment’s sustainability and societal impact.

Here at Antler, we are on a mission to fundamentally improve the world by enabling the world's most exceptional people to build the sector-defining companies of tomorrow. Here is our take on ESG from the VC perspective.

antler

Author

Antler

The investor backing the world's most driven founders, from day zero to greatness. Enabling thousands of founders every year to launch and scale companies that move the world forward.

As ESG is a relatively new concept, and as we recently discussed on FT's Sifted, there is no universally accepted way to measure ESG implementation for a VC.

Even though there are internationally recognized ESG frameworks that are used in multinational businesses, which are used to measure the deployment and impact of ESG policies, these have yet to find a universal way to measure ESG implementation in VC.

At Antler, we want to change that. It is important to us that both Antler and our portfolio companies create sustainable value, make a positive contribution to the world, and lead the way in terms of diversity.

Why should VCs implement ESG?

From our experience, the vast majority of the founders we work with have high standards for ESG; and more LPs, especially the larger institutions, are now pushing funds for more clarity on their implementation of ESG.

The implementation of ESG at the early stages can vastly improve portfolio performance. Companies that implement ESG typically perform 4.8% better than those that do not, according to HBS. These companies performed better when considering accounting rates or return, ROE, and ROA.

According to research conducted by Deutsche Bank which evaluated 56 academic studies, 89% of these studies showed that companies with high ESG factors outperformed the market in the medium (3-5 years) and long (5-10 years) term.

Furthermore, Limited Partners increasingly expect VC funds to demonstrate a meaningful approach to responsible investment. According to a survey conducted on 22 000 investors by Schroders Global Investor Study, 78% of investors felt that sustainable investing is more important now (in 2017) compared to 5 years ago, and 64% had increased their sustainable investments over the past 5 years.

It is worth considering the end-users of portfolio companies' products and services, too. Nowadays, the purchasing decisions of customers, especially millennials, are increasingly values-driven. In light of climate change and gender inequality, consumers demand solutions that not only mitigate any negative impact on the environment and society but also contribute to improving the global state of affairs.

What goals should VCs monitor

VC's will probably want to monitor the ESG impact of their fund, and that of their portfolio companies.

Using the guidelines you have chosen and formalised for your fund (such as the UN PRI, which we talk about below), VCs should create measurable goals. Without goals, you do not have an effective ESG policy. But having clear objectives will confirm when ESG accomplishments have been hit (or missed).

Quantitative goals include tracking the number of jobs created, the number of women employed in white-collar roles, estimation of potential contribution to GDP, effect on climate change, emissions etc.; and qualitative targets can include CSR strategy, directional statements, and formalized guidelines.

Once a VC decides what they want to measure, they need to ensure that ESG implementation and monitoring are incorporated into both the investment decision-making and portfolio tracking processes.

Going further, some LPs may require you to provide an annual ESG summary, so it is useful to develop best practices

How to integrate and manage ESG goals in VC

We are working on implementing ESG considerations in three stages over the coming months:

a) Pre-investment DD (due diligence): Our investment team assesses each investment opportunity, fills out an ESG DD survey, explains any considerations, and tags the UN SDG goals fulfilled through each opportunity, which are all considered as input for investment decisions and shared with the Investment Committee (IC) members ahead of the committee date.

b) Once we make investments: We encourage all our portfolio companies to agree to our ESG Principles which outline first-level principles and good practices and help us increase our portfolio companies' awareness and get their commitment. We are currently in the progress of incorporating these into our legal investment documentation to ask for an even firmer commitment from each of our portfolio companies.

c) Post investment: Once a year we will ask our portfolio companies a number of questions regarding their work and impact on the environment and society around them, and their policies, and we conduct an ESG-focused training for them.

Guideline: The UN Principles for Responsible Investing

It is almost impossible to draw up ESG guidelines from scratch, so it is best to follow the best practices of others. We have used the UN PRI's ESG guidelines as the basis of our own ESG practices.

As such, Antler has chosen to become a signatory of the United Nations' Principles for Responsible Investment (UN PRI) and has chosen to be guided by the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals ("UN SDG"). The UN PRI is the world's leading proponent of responsible investing, and as a signatory, Antler follows ESG principles as guidelines for its investment decision-making process.

Under the guidance of these goals, we are committed to improving the ESG impact of our own investing, and to helping our portfolio companies incorporate ESG considerations into their operational decisions.

This will better enable both Antler, and our portfolio companies, to improve health and education, reduce inequality, and spur economic growth in the locations in which we are present, and through the companies we build. We are also committed to ensuring that our portfolio companies make meaningful contributions to GDP, and job growth in the regions in which they are based.

ESG challenges for a VC

Regardless of many opportunities, embracing ESG in VCs operations carries some challenges.

Firstly, monitoring the ESG impact of a certain startup can be arduous given the early-stage phase of business which is most often nascent; startups seeking funding at VCs usually have little to no operations and therefore have no business processes that would pose ESG risks.

Secondly, invested companies usually have limited to no ESG know-how, so for this reason they may be hesitant to take VCs' advice to adopt ESG practices. As a minority stakeholder in startups, VCs typically have little influence over the startups' course of action. Moreover, they may be hesitant to adopt ESG practices as they may see it as something that would cost more resources than traditional methods. From the startups' perspective, sourcing materials from an environmentally friendly supplier could be more costly, and putting in place all ESG measures could be time-consuming.

Thirdly, oftentimes VCs report their ESG efforts the same way PEs do. However, the means used to measure PEs' performance would vary from VCs' due to their typical portfolio and stage at which it invests.

---

We believe ESG will become commonplace, even though it's not broadly adopted as yet. Not only does responsible investing help both investors and their portfolio companies drive better performance, but it also will work towards creating a better world. For us, it's a no-brainer.

Here at Antler, we are still in the learning process, trying to figure out the best ESG practices for a VC ourselves. In order to achieve the best results, we are open to hearing from other VCs and engaging in a discussion related to ESG in the VC's world.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Get the latest news and views from Antler’s global community

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Must-read articles from Antler

Browse our collection of founder stories, industry insights and latest startup successes from Antler Australia

See articles
Founder Stories
5 min read
Sharon Li & Vanessa Chen: Empowering employees to be their healthiest and most productive selves

“People sometimes think the emotional and professional are conflicting, but what we believe is when people love their organization, the emotional value will actually make them productive. It will make them give their full self to the organization and make the organization grow for the long term.” —Sharon Li, co-founder and CEO of CHOYS

Founder Stories
5 min read
Piet Hein van Dam: The seasoned data entrepreneur aiming to eradicate type 2 diabetes

Our content series "It All Starts with People" delves into the passions, motivations, and vision of the exceptional founders we have the privilege of partnering with around the world. Bringing a clarity of vision to our latest spotlight is Piet Hein van Dam, co-founder of Clear, the award-winning digital self-help tool for diabetes patients.

Insights
5 min read
Unpacking the $80+ billion ONDC opportunity: India’s next startup catalyst

India's approach to unbundle payments made the world look up and take notice. Now it's time to disrupt commerce with the Open Network for Digital Commerce or ONDC. In our latest Theory of Next deep dive we mapped, researched, and reached out to every network participant live on ONDC right now.


And we're excited to share with you a comprehensive what could be India's next unicorn catalyst with inputs from Vibhor Jain (COO of ONDC), Sujith Nair (Founding member of Beckn Protocol), and founders building on ONDC!

Co-authored by Nitin Sharma (Partner, Antler) and Gokul Kumaravelu.

Insights
5 min read
Five steps investors can take to support more diverse founders

Despite growing calls to create a more inclusive venture capital ecosystem and remove the barriers to entrepreneurship, only a fraction of funding is raised by founders from underrepresented communities.

The first step towards change is quantifying the challenge. While in-depth research has been conducted about women founders and founders from ethnic minority backgrounds, data has never existed about tech founders from the LGBTQ+ community—until now.

Insights
5 min read
A record year for Europe's leading day zero investor

A look back at 2022, a record year for the leading day zero investor in Europe—showcasing investment activity and key predictions for the early-stage tech ecosystem in 2023.

Founder Stories
5 min read
Antler and Microsoft for Startups partner to back women founders

Antler is proud to join forces with Microsoft for Startups to support rising entrepreneurs—starting with 23 non-dilutive grants to women founders in South Asia, Southeast Asia, and North America—and reduce the barriers to startup success. Meet some of these founders.

Founder Stories
5 min read
Tanika McLeod: The educator empowering the next generation with an on-demand social learning platform

Our content series—"It All Starts with People"—delves into the passions, motivations, and vision of the exceptional founders we have the privilege of partnering with around the world. In our latest spotlight, we spoke with Tanika McLeod, one of the three co-founders behind MinuteSkill, a Toronto-based social micro-learning platform that uses bite-sized content and knowledge-sharing communities to empower the next generation.

Insights
5 min read
Venture capital as an engine of positive transformation

Antler's second annual ESG and Impact Report shares learnings on how VCs can focus on creating sustainable value from the outset, and celebrates our portfolio companies' work in this space.